For the third year running Catherine Wilmers and friends have performed in Baldock Church raising funds for The RevIvel Association. This year they performed the beautiful Mozart Piano Quartet in G minor and the stunning Faure Piano Quartet no.1 together with Mahler’s early Piano Quartet. The audience was delighted with the concert. Professor Nick Rogers introduced it and it ended with a première of a piece specially composed for the concert by Frances Matthews, daughter of one of our wonderful campaigning committee members Nick Balmer. Her piece was for piano quartet and audience titled ‘Let Our River Heal’. Thanks to sponsors (with wonderful raffle prizes) and advertisers Chapmans Butchers, Fairhaven, Nortonway Gallery, Priory Picnincs, System Restore,
Richard reason Pianos, ‘Eight’ (Restaurant in Baldock), The Three Horseshoes (Norton) and Richard Meredith Hardy for their generosity. The concert really spreads the word about Revivel in a most enjoyable way and in a beautiful setting, St. Mary’s Church in Baldock which we were allowed to use as well as raising about £1500 for our fight for the health of the upper River Ivel.
membership
Dear Members and Supporters,
I thought, in the light of the huge changes to the River Ivel in Baldock, you might appreciate an
update of what RevIvel’s view of these developments is and where we go from here. Many of you
may have seen my short piece in the February copy of On Our Doorstep. This is a more detailed
discussion of where we are, and what we plan to do in the future.
RevIvel’s headline aim is to restore flow to the Ivel to allow the re-establishment of Brown Trout
and other critical species in our much-neglected river. That requires year-round flow of
suƯicient quantity and quality such has not been seen in the Ivel for many years, maybe many
decades. A quick stroll across the wildflower meadow currently reveals the result of the recent
Ivel makeover, courtesy of AƯinity Water and their contractors, Five Rivers. Much money has
been spent on landscaping, digging out and lining the main river channels with gravel and
creating potential wetland landscapes where the boardwalk crosses the river. And the river is
flowing as vigorously as many of us can remember with much of that coming from the Ivel
Springs themselves. So, you may feel that RevIvel’s work is done – the river is flowing, the water
looks clear (most of the time) and once the landscaping has healed and is covered in greenery
all will be well. We can pack up our bags, move on and stop bothering everyone about chalk
streams and their ecosystems.
It would be very nice if this were true. But you must remember that AƯinity are still abstracting
huge amounts of water from the aquifer which has only recovered this year because we have
just experienced the wettest winter on record. This has replenished the aquifer at a rate that
even AƯinity are not allowed to exceed. As spring moves into summer, the aquifer level will drop
as the rate of abstraction exceeds the rate of replenishment, although because of the wet winter
there is a good chance the Ivel springs will continue to flow throughout the season, albeit at a
much-reduced rate. Another dry winter and the river will once again be reduced to the dry
channel so familiar from recent summers and AƯinity’s landscaping will have been all in vain.
In addition to over-abstraction, there remains the risk of further leaks from the poorly
maintained Baldock sewage pumping station. This facility pumps all our foul waste to the
Letchworth sewage plant and over the past three years there have been several incidents where
raw sewage has leaked from this system, either from breaks in the rising main that takes the
sewage to Letchworth, or directly from the pumping station where the infrastructure requires a
radical updating. You may have noticed the growth of brown algae lining much of the recently
excavated channel of the Ivel, particularly near the boardwalk. This is a direct result of sewage
leakage from the pumping station adding extra nutrients to the water which encourages algal
growth. The gravel bed of a chalk stream should be clearly visible through the water and be free
of such unpleasantness. When the flow reduces the negative eƯects caused by any sewage
spillage will become more marked simply because the sewage is less diluted by the clean flow,
and it hangs around for longer. Flow-rate and water quality are clearly inter-related.
RevIvel’s plan for the restoration of natural flow in the upper Ivel and the Ivel Springs is for
AƯinity to cease abstraction from their Baldock boreholes, allow the aquifer to replenish
naturally and the springs and river to return to their more natural state. Water could then be
taken from the Ivel further downstream, piped into Grafham Water and subsequently fed into
the water supply via existing pipework. This scheme was described in detail by John Lawson, our
consultant in his report of 2 years ago. By contrast, AƯinity Water’s plan to maintain flow in the
Ivel is called augmentation, in which the aquifer depletion caused by abstraction is compensated by water from a newly drilled borehole near the springs pumped into the river
when the flow drops below a critical level.
We have several criticisms of this plan, not the least of which is the pathetically low flow rate
they are planning to supply – 0.5 Megalitres/day – while John Lawson’s modelling shows the
minimum flow should be almost 10 time this amount. Recently this figure was corroborated by a
study using a diƯerent modelling technique in work commissioned by AƯinity and Anglian Water
to investigate the feasibility of implementing the Lawson plan. While we await the written report
from this work, all parties are aware of the results but seem reluctant to modify their original
augmentation scheme. So, you can see, that the while we have made some inroads into
exposing the weaknesses in AƯinity Water’s overall plan, there is much work to be done if we are
to get back to something like a natural flow year-round in the Upper Ivel.
Another threat to the Ivel, and indeed the whole of Baldock is the proposed new housing
development and the potential doubling in size of Baldock over the coming decades. Three
thousand more houses will require a lot of water and will generate a lot of sewage. Where will
the water come from and where will the sewage go? How will this aƯect the Ivel? Moreover, if
you build houses and roads over porous agricultural land, this produces more storm run-oƯ that
rapidly finds its way into the river, unless something is done to stop it. What is being done to
manage run-oƯ? RevIvel has been posing these questions to Urban and Civic, the Master
Planners currently in charge of mapping out the new development on behalf of the Council. We
have developed good relations with U & C over the past 18 months and have submitted a
document to them with 19 ‘Blue Asks’ that require positive answers if they are to live up to their
stated claims of sustainability and environmental care. So far, our consultations with them have
been positive but we remain vigilant that our proposals become integrated into the final plans.
Meanwhile we continue our lobbying of the water companies, the Environment Agency and
various Quangos related to the water industry. To aid in this work we retain the services of John
Lawson, together with support from Charles Rangely-Wilson who heads up the Chalk Streams
First initiative and chairs various panels and committees concerned with water quality and the
health of the nation’s rivers. Without this expertise and other connections, we would not be able
to have the influence we exert or contribute to discussions concerning our river and rivers more
generally.
As for our plans, this year we will construct a water flow gauge at Radwell on that stretch of the
river owned by Richard-Meredith Hardy, one of our founder committee members. The upper Ivel
currently has no flow gauges, and this addition will allow us to quantify how river flow varies
throughout the year on this previously unmonitored stretch. In addition, we aim to introduce a
programme of regular environmental monitoring, sampling for river fly, e. coli and hopefully
water chemistry, thereby giving us a picture of the overall health of the river which we can then
feed into various national and regional programmes focussing on river ecosystems.
Finally, a note on various forthcoming events. In addition to the members walk on 28th April,
there is another walk as part of the Baldock festival on16th May. We’ll have a stall in the Street
Fair on Saturday 18th May and there is the Bubbly Concert in aid of RevIvel, kindly organised by
Catherine Wilmers in St Mary’s Church, Baldock. This will be on Sunday 12th May at 5.30. We
also plan to be at the Stotfold Steam fair in October and the Letchworth G. C. Classic and
Vintage Car event on June 8th. This will be held at Fairclough Farm, Halls Green, near Weston.
Do come along and have a chat, or if you’d like to volunteer to help at one of these events or with
our future programme of environmental monitoring then send us an email.
I must end with a big thank you to all members and supporters. Your donations and
subscriptions allow us to campaign on behalf of the community to raise awareness of the plight
of our local river and help restore it to something resembling its natural state. Here’s looking
forward to the return of Brown Trout to Radwell and Baldock!
Nick Rogers,
RevIvel Chair
10th April 2024
2023 has been a year of significant progress for RevIvel in its aim of restoring year-round water in
the Ivel Springs and flow to the river. Importantly our membership numbers and those of our
supporters grew so that there are now about 200 individuals contributing financially towards our
activities. We are increasingly known in the district and within the broader ‘water community’ as an
effective and active organisation fighting for river remediation and restoration. And our work with
the water industry through our various contacts and our consultant, John Lawson, has led to a better
understanding of how the Ivel works and what needs to be done in the future.
The year started off with a major event in January at which we launched our film (Restoring theUpper Ivel – YouTube). This had been commissioned by RevIvel in 2022 and made by Parick Rangely
and Kathryn McKenzie of RevIvel. We had ambitiously booked the hall at Knights Templar School
with three scheduled screenings at hourly intervals throughout the afternoon and were anxious that
no-one would come. Fortunately, even though the weather was, to say the least, inclement, the hall
was packed for much of the afternoon. The audience of about 250 included many members and
non-members from Baldock, as well as county and district councillors and interested parties from
much further afield. Not to mention representatives from Affinity Water and the Environment
Agency who were there to see what we were getting up to. There was a real sense that RevIvel’s
message was getting through.
Our major fundraising event of the year was a concert of classical music put on by Catherine Wilmers
in St Mary’s Church. Catherine is a well-known and highly regarded cellist who plays regularly at
concerts in the UK and across Europe and this was the second such concert Catherine has organised
for our benefit. She assembled a group of professional musicians who presented us with a beautiful
evening of music by a variety of composers which entertained us for over two hours. The
programme also featured a new work written by Frances Matthews, the daughter of Nick Balmer,
one of our committee members. Entitled Cry me a River, it involved some audience participation and
given the cause of the event, was very well received by the 150 or so present.
Later in the summer, a chance encounter with local political activists, supposedly across the kitchen
table at Radwell Mill, provided Richard Meredith Hardy the opportunity to press the case for the Ivel
and Chalk Streams in general. This set a series of subsequent meetings in train involving Sir Oliver
Heald, who chairs the All-party committee on The Protection of Chalk Streams, plus supporters of all
parties in the House of Lords. The result was the addition of a clause in the Levelling Up and
Regeneration Bill that afforded legal protection for all Chalk Streams across the UK.
The River Ivel achieved further fame nationally when Kathryn McKenzie represented RevIvel in a
feature on Chalk Streams and the pressures they face on the BBC programme, Countryfile (BBC iPlayer – Countryfile – Porthcawl Surf and Sand). The feature was broadcast in June and lasted 13
minutes (starting 10 minutes into the programme) with Kathryn being interviewed on the banks of
the Ivel – yet another example of the reach our organisation is achieving.
Most recently, during November and just in time for the AGM, we were briefed on the results of Ivel
catchment modelling that Affinity Water and Anglian Water commissioned as a result of the Lawson
Report (Ivel-report-21.6.21-BHs-redacted.pdf (revivel.org)). You may recall that the Lawson Report
proposes a model whereby water abstraction from the boreholes near Baldock should be limited to
10% of the current rate and the aquifer and river allowed to recover naturally. Water could then be
abstracted from the river at Offord, where it joins the Ouse and fed into Grafham Water and hence
into the drinking water system. The new modelling is based on a revised and improved data set of
river flows, rainfall and geology and, in a nutshell, confirms the conclusions John Lawson reached
last year. We are now putting more pressure on Affinity to take this investigation from the desk to
real life and switch off the water abstraction to let the river flow again. This in line with an approach
known as Chalk Streams First (Chalk-Streams First – Chalk-Streams (chalkstreams.org)), and if
applied to the Ivel, could be a pilot study that could then be applied to rivers elsewhere.
In addition to the highlights above, members of RevIvel have continued to present our case through
talks and other activities to general interest groups locally and throughout the region. Revival has
also make representations to Urban and Civic, master planners for the ‘Growth of Baldock’ scheme,
regarding effective waste-water management and ‘blue’ infrastructure in the development.
As I hope you will appreciate from the above examples, much of what we do is planned, while other
achievements have been opportunistic. The strength of our organisation is that we can tap into a
wide range of experience, expertise and contacts in our core committee and in the wider
membership to take advantage of opportunities as and when they arise
Our future activities are now geared to pushing the water industry to implement the Lawson Report,
installing a flow monitoring station closer to the source of the Ivel and developing a programme of
river quality monitoring, once flow has been restored.
Finally, I would like to thank everyone involved in RevIvel for their support, work and dedication over
the past year. I am continually amazed by what you have achieved. Here’s to even greater progress
in 2024!
Nick Rogers
ReIvel Chair
November 2023
RevIvel’s Annual General Meeting was held on Wednesday evening 22nd November at St Marys Church Hall, Baldock.
The meeting was exceptionally well attended, and the committee would like to thank all those members and supporters that came along.
Chair Nick Rogers opened proceedings and welcomed everybody.
Kathryn Mackenzie presented a report on the past year’s events and successes.
Tony Woodman presented the financial statement for the year and an update on membership levels.
Beth Hall presented Revivel’s future plans for 2024.
The keynote speaker was Jon Balaam from The Greensand Trust who gave a very interesting and informative talk on ‘The importance of communities in river restoration’ explaining that the catchment based way is to work together, aiming for healthier rivers, richer in wildlife valued by all.
Following the meeting Chair Nick Rogers produced RevIvel : The Hightlights of 2023
Next years Annual General Meeting will be held at Radwell Village Hall on November 19th 2024.
There is very little understanding on the part of our government and water company staff of the
importance of the Cat Ditch catchment to the Ivel.
This is illustrated by the following map published by the Upper & Bedford Ouse Catchment
Partnership map, that incorrectly labels the Cat Ditch as the River Ivel, while not identifying the Ivel
branch that runs into Baldock at all.
DEFRA & the EA recognise that the River Ivel is made up of several discrete water bodies &
catchments.
The branch of the River Ivel that flows up via Radwell to Baldock is called the “Ivel (US Henlow)
Water Body.
DEFRA & the EA assign the following catchment areas to the Henlow to Baldock branch of the Ivel.
DEFRA & the EA then go on to assign the following key attributes to the Cat Ditch catchment.
Taken together the total lengths and areas appear to be as follows.
As recharge & runoff is a function of areas, it can readily be appreciated how the Cat Ditch is more important to the flows in the Ivel downstream of Astwick (the confluence) than the Ivel.
From the following marked map of the Ivel Catchment which shows the approximate limit of the permeable chalk strata in dark blue, & the Bedfordshire Gault clay that is very much less permeable, in light blue, it can be readily appreciated that the effective chalk catchment area associated with the Baldock Ivel is much smaller still.
Taking into consideration that much of the Ivel Catchment described by DEFRA & the EA (in figure 2) is either underlain by impermeable Gaults, or overlain by impermeable urban areas, it can be appreciated that the key attributes of the Baldock Ivel & Cat Ditch are as follows.
At less than 29% of the effective permeable area underlying the former Ivel catchment no longer available to recharge, it can be appreciated why Ivel Springs have failed for the past three years. In the face of unsustainably high levels of abstraction by Affinity Water, there is little or no chance of these springs returning.
The situation by 2040 will be even more dire, as the effective Ivel Catchment over Chalk will reduce
from 1737 hectares in 2023 to 1611 hectares.
We have to protect the Cat Ditch Catchment, & then enhance its physical properties by working with the existing land owners to farm for water as a crop, rather than casting it aside as a problem.
1 https://ubocp.org.uk/catchments/ivel/
2 https://environment.data.gov.uk/catchment-planning/WaterBody/GB105033037720
3 https://environment.data.gov.uk/catchment-planning/WaterBody/GB105033037720
4 https://environment.data.gov.uk/catchment-planning/WaterBody/GB105033037740
Kindly produced by Nick Balmar
Water situation for Upper Ivel – September 2023.
All data presented courtesy of the Environment Agency and Met Office (Crown copy right 2023)
Rainfall:
There was a heatwave in early September, with the highest temperatures of the year in East Anglia being recorded during the month. During the second half of the month, high pressure gave way to the low-pressure systems coming in from the Atlantic this being more typical of autumn conditions. This resulted in above average rainfall (130%) in
the Upper Bedford Ouse catchment.
Soil Moisture Deficit (SMD)
The soil moisture deficits [SMD] by the end of September had reduced to 70-80mm and was considered in the normal range for this time of year.
Soil Moisture deficits for week ending 30 Sept 2023. Data based on weekly MORECS data for real land use and compared to an analysis of historic 1961 – 1990 LTA dataset.
Definitions:
Soil Moisture deficit (SMD) – The difference between the amount of water in the soil and the amount of water that the soil can hold (field capacity).
Ground Water (GW):
The groundwater levels across East Anglia’s western region continued to recede through September as expected for this time of year but remain in the normal range compared to historic levels.
Springs and River Flows:
The main spring at Ivel Springs in Baldock started to flow on 14 th January 2023 but has ceased to flow as of 24 th June 2023, effective flowing for only 23 weeks in the year. This spring should flow year-round albeit at reduced flow levels in late summer / early autumn….Historically the mill at Blackhorse (closed in 1870s) would have milled wheat
year-round for the people of Baldock and surrounding villages.
The second spring at the Ivel Springs nature reserve (upstream of culvert) in Baldock started to flow on 1 st January 2023. Surprisingly we have continued to see a minimal flow into September, albeit at extremely low levels. This is important as it has allowed a slow recovery of flora and fauna in the upper reaches.
Flow at Blackhorse mill started by the end of the first week in January 2023.Again we are pleased to report that there is still minimal flow at Blackhorse mill at the end of September 2023.
The river Ivel flows are officially measured at Blunham. Heavy rain events in the second half of September saw a spike in flow which returned to normal by the end of the month(Green Zone).
Reservoir Stocks:
Water from the Ouse is transferred at Offord into Grafham Water reservoir. After twelve months of reduced capacity Grafham Water reservoir has finally returned to full capacity during June – Sept 2023 (90% -blue line on graph) which is in line with the normal operating levels.
End of Sept 2023 Grafham Water reservoir stock compared to the Normal operating Curve, Drought Curve and 1995-1996 stock levels.
Looking forward:
The upper reaches of the Ivel have managed to maintain a minimal level of flow throughout the summer months. This is the best outcome we could have hoped for considering the previous 18 months and continued abstraction practises of Affinity Water.
Looking forward this autumn Affinity Water will start the river restoration at Ivel Spring Nature Reserve so look out for some channel improvement works. Also, we can expect “testing’ of the augmentation scheme to get underway. So, look out for activity at the Ivel Spring. The current planned augmentation of a mere 0.54 Ml /day is far short of the desired re-naturalisation of flow Revivel demand but at least we should no longer see a dry riverbed all the way to Radwell.
Revitalising the River Ivel’ – Construction at Ivel Springs Nature Reserve
Affinity Water have appointed the FiveRivers team and they will be starting the seasonal wetland and river restoration construction on Monday 6th November at Ivel Springs Nature Reserve. The latest information and detailed designs are available on their website: https://www.
20th September, Ian Hall and Kathryn Mackenzie of RevIvel presented to the Baldock Community Forum chaired by Urban&Civic (U&C) master developers.
RevIvel highlighted requirements, best practices and suggestions relating to water, with
sustainability, aquifer health and community wellbeing in mind.
Here is a short summary of the points raised:
1. Supply of Drinking Water
This is a key issue as we live in a semi-arid, water-stressed area. There is no new water available locally.
RevIvel emphasised that the new development should not be:
Detrimental to any chalk stream in this area
Used as a “bargaining tool” to weaken existing environmental commitments
2. Sewerage
Issue: Groundwater has been polluted by four sewage “spillages” in the last three years.
RevIvel requested that:
The new sewerage system must be constructed to the highest environmental standards and adopt best practices
No overflows should be fitted at pipes or pumping stations
There will be adequate storage within the system to cope with dry and wet weather flows
3. Other
RevIvel sought confirmation that:
The new development will be water neutral, which is best practice
There will be compulsory (smart) metering in the new homes and to explore tiered pricing
and capping measures to encourage reduced consumption
4. Sustainable Drainage Systems (SuDS)
It is best practice in chalk catchments to use SuDS to encourage infiltration throughout the
development to contribute to aquifer recharge and support groundwater; this means SuDS should capture/ reutilise as much water as possible within the site and reduce run off.
RevIvel highlighted the following as best practice:
a. Within the new homes
Features such as permeable driveways and water butts
Integrated plumbing: to ensure grey and rainwater is re-utilised to e.g. flush toilets
Fixtures and fittings which meet water efficiency best practice
b. Outside the new homes
Implement permeable road and paving surfaces everywhere
Implement SuDS across the whole site and in a joined-up way
Install flow inhibitors at discharge points (as chalk streams need a constant flow)
5. Hydrological Features
Opportunities for daylighting/ deculverting were mentioned at the consultation event.
RevIvel asked what has been highlighted in the site surveys?
An historic winterbourne stream runs through the site; RevIvel asked that this should be
respected, not treated as a drainage ditch
6. The Bigger Picture/ Future-Proofing
RevIvel flagged the following:
The need to keep abreast of the Levelling Up and Communities Bill (amendment contains
protection for chalk streams), as this will impact the planning process
That the Environment Agency (EA) has been vocal lately about new developments. RevIvel asked for confirmation that the EA had been consulted and asked what had been stipulated?
That the Pix Brook already floods; more recycled sewage water could make this worse.
Please investigate potential impact
That planning/ design needs to be future-proofed i.e. ironically if abstraction were reduced, groundwater could rise
Outcome
U&C thanked RevIvel for the presentation and the suggestions.
There was useful discussion and furthermore, U&C confirmed that all the points (19!) raised by RevIvel were valid to take forward for further evaluation. This meeting was the latest in a series of helpful discussions with further progress meetings to be scheduled.
A reminder that the next public consultation events are scheduled for 24th and 25th November 2023 at St Mary’s Church Hall in Baldock.
Water situation for Upper Ivel – July- August 2023
All data presented courtesy of the Environment Agency and Met Office (Crown copy right 2023)
Rainfall:
We had a particularly wet July, with 210% of Long-Term Average (LTA) in the Upper Bedford Ouse catchment. This was then followed by August which started wet but became increasingly dry as the month progressed. As the end of August sees the end of meteorological summer, the 3-month average (June- Aug 2023) for our catchment was 105% (normal) of LTA. The spring and summer combined can be considered as notably high, averaging 128% of the long- term average for our catchment area.
Soil Moisture Deficit (SMD)
The soil moisture deficits [SMD] by the end of August was 100+mm, and in the normal range for this time of year. Soil Moisture deficits for week ending 31 Aug 2023. Data based on weekly MORECS data for real land use and compared to an analysis of historic 1961 – 1990 LTA dataset.
Definitions:
Soil Moisture deficit (SMD) – The difference between the amount of water in the soil and the amount of water that the soil can hold (field capacity).
Ground Water (GW):
The groundwater levels across East Anglia’s western region continued to recede throughout the summer months as expected for this time of year but remain in the Normal range compared to historic levels.
Springs and River flows:
The main spring at Ivel Springs in Baldock started to flow on 14 th January 2023 but has ceased to flow as of 24 th June 2023, effective flowing for only 23 weeks in the year. This spring should flow year-round albeit at reduced flow levels in late summer / early autumn….Historically the mill at Blackhorse (closed in 1870s) would have milled wheat year-round for the people of Baldock and surrounding villages.
The second spring at the Ivel Springs nature reserve (upstream of culvert) in Baldock started to flow on 1 st January 2023. Surprisingly we have continued to see a minimal flow throughout July August, meaning we do have water along the whole Ivel form the head spring downward. This is important as it has allowed a slow recovery of flora and fauna in the upper reaches. Flow at Blackhorse mill started by the end of the first week in January 2023.Again we are pleased to report that there is still flow at Blackhorse mill at the end of August 2023.
The river Ivel flows are officially measured at Blunham. Heavy rain events in July saw increased flow which returned to normal during August (Green Zone).
Reservoir Stocks:
Water from the Ouse is transferred at Offord into Grafham Water reservoir. After twelve months of reduced capacity Grafham Water reservoir has finally returned to full capacity during June – Aug 2023 (94% -blue line on graph) which is in line with the normal operating level of 90%+.
End of June 2023 Grafham Water reservoir stock compared to the Normal operating Curve, Drought Curve and 1995-1996 stock levels.
Looking forward:
The Upper Bedford Ouse catchment has been in official “drought” from June 2022 until May 2023. The exceptional rain fall in March and continued aquifer recharge into mid-May 2023 has thankfully resulted in a change in status to “Recovering Drought. Despite the “summer” 3-month period with rainfall at 106% of the Long-Term Average the upper Bedford Ouse remains in “Recovering Drought.”
For the nine months period of drought experienced in 2022/ 2023 Affinity did not instigate any hosepipe bans instead they continued to pump water from the ground and allowed the river to dry all the way from Baldock to Radwell (acknowledged result of their Drought Plan).
Since 2019, RevIvel have been highlighting the plight of the chalk headwaters of the Ivel. Throughout this time Affinity Water have been making all the right noises, however more water has been taken from the aquifer than ever before!
Consequently, the river Ivel and its associated flora and fauna continues to suffer……..